Guide · Set-up

Cold email domains: secondary domains explained

Short answer

Cold email senders send from secondary domains, such as getyourbrand.com, so that complaints or blocks never touch the main company domain your staff and customers use. Each secondary domain redirects to the main website, carries a few mailboxes, and needs its own MX, SPF, DKIM and DMARC records.

Written by Outboxes, which sells private SMTP mailboxes for cold email: one of the options this guide describes.

Why not send cold email from your main domain?

Reputation belongs to a domain. If cold outreach from yourbrand.com draws spam complaints or lands on a blocklist, the same domain's invoices, support replies and staff email suffer with it. Separate sending domains put a wall between outreach and the mail your business depends on.

There is a second reason: volume. Spreading outreach over several domains keeps each one's daily volume modest. See how many mailboxes and domains.

How should you name secondary domains?

A recipient should recognise the brand. Common patterns:

PatternExample for "Acme"Notes
Prefixgetacme.com, tryacme.com, meetacme.comThe most common pattern; reads naturally
Suffixacmehq.com, acmeteam.com, acmemail.comKeeps the brand first
Other extensionacme.io, acme.coUse extensions your audience already trusts
Hyphenatedacme-team.comWorks, but harder to say aloud

Our recommendation: keep the brand name intact, avoid misspellings that look like impersonation of someone else, and avoid words such as "mail" or "outreach" where a plainer name works. Never register a name that imitates another company's brand.

Keep the names consistent across a set, so a recipient who sees two of them recognises the same company, and use the same sender names and signature on every domain.

Should secondary domains redirect to your main site?

Yes. A recipient who types the domain into a browser, or a filter that checks it, should find a real business. Point each secondary domain at the main website with a permanent HTTP redirect (status 301). The redirect is a web setting; it does not affect mail, which follows the MX record.

How many mailboxes should each domain carry?

Providers publish small numbers: Inboxlogy and Mailreef recommend at most 3 mailboxes per domain, Outreach2day at most 5. Fewer mailboxes per domain spreads risk further but means buying more domains. Our recommendation for new domains is 3. You can add mailboxes to a domain later, once it has a steady history.

Should you register new domains or bring your own?

  • Register through the mailbox provider when you want the DNS set up without touching a registrar. Check that the domain is registered in your name and can be transferred out.
  • Bring your own when you already own suitable domains or want them all at one registrar. You then add the DNS records the provider gives you.

Domain registration is usually a separate yearly cost and, unlike the mailbox plan, usually not refundable once registered. A brand-new domain has no history, so it needs warm-up before campaigns: see cold email warm-up.

Which DNS records does each sending domain need?

RecordHostPurpose
MXthe domainWhere replies to your mailboxes are delivered
SPF (TXT)the domainWhich servers may send for the domain
DKIM (TXT or CNAME)selector._domainkeyThe public key that verifies message signatures
DMARC (TXT)_dmarcPolicy and reports for messages that fail
Tracking domain (CNAME)a subdomain, such as trackOpen and click tracking under your own domain instead of the sequencer's shared one
Web redirectthe domain and wwwSends visitors to the main site

See SPF, DKIM and DMARC for example records. Outboxes configures and tests all of the mail records on each domain it hosts.

When should you retire a sending domain?

Watch each domain separately in your sequencer. Signs that a domain is in trouble: bounces or spam placement rising on that domain while others stay steady, replies drying up, or the domain appearing on a public blocklist.

Our recommendation: pause campaigns on the domain first and look for the cause, which is often a list or a volume change rather than the domain itself. If the domain is listed or keeps failing after the cause is fixed, retire it and bring a new domain into warm-up. Keep a retired domain registered for a while, so nobody else can buy it and send under a name your recipients know. Plan for a few spare domains in warm-up if your outreach cannot pause.

Sources

  1. Inboxlogy pricing (mailboxes per domain)
  2. Mailreef pricing (mailboxes per domain)
  3. Outreach2day pricing (mailboxes per domain)
  4. MDN: 301 Moved Permanently
  5. ICANN: Registering a domain name
  6. Google: Email sender guidelines

Questions

Can I send cold email from my main domain?

You can, but complaints or blocks would then affect all of the company's email. Most senders use secondary domains to keep that risk away from the main domain.

How many secondary domains do I need?

Divide the mailboxes you need by the mailboxes per domain, for example 3. For 30 mailboxes at 3 per domain, that is 10 domains.

Should a secondary domain have a website?

It should redirect to your main website with a permanent redirect, so anyone who visits it finds your business.

Do secondary domains need warm-up?

Yes. A newly registered domain has no sending history and needs about two weeks of warm-up before campaigns.

Related guides and tools

From €0.67 per inbox · 25 inboxes minimum

See pricing