Guide · Deliverability

Shared vs dedicated IP for cold email

Short answer

On a shared IP, your mail goes out from addresses other customers also use, so you share their reputation. A dedicated IP or server sends only your mail, so the reputation is yours alone, good or bad, and it needs steady volume to stay established. Dedicated options cost more. Neither guarantees inbox placement.

Written by Outboxes, which sells private SMTP mailboxes for cold email: one of the options this guide describes.

What is IP reputation?

Receiving mail services keep a record of how mail from each sending IP address behaves: volume, bounces, spam complaints, spam-trap hits and whether recipients engage. That record is the IP's reputation. It sits alongside the reputation of the sending domain, and both feed the decision to accept a message and where to file it. Public blocklists such as those run by Spamhaus list IPs and domains seen sending spam.

How do a shared pool, a dedicated IP and a dedicated server differ?

  • Shared pool. Many customers' mailboxes send from the same set of IPs, often rotated. The provider manages the pool's reputation; one bad customer can affect the rest until the provider removes them.
  • Dedicated IP. One or more IPs used only by you, usually on the provider's shared server software. Your volume alone builds and keeps the IP's reputation.
  • Dedicated server. A whole mail server, with its IPs, for one customer. Common for agencies, who put all their clients on it, and for teams sending high volume every day.

What are the trade-offs?

QuestionShared poolDedicated IPDedicated server
Isolation from other customersNone at IP levelAt IP levelFull, server and IPs
Who carries the reputationAll customers on the pool, managed by the providerYouYou and, for agencies, all your clients
Volume neededNone of your ownSteady daily volume, or the IP has too little history to judgeSteady volume across all domains on it
CostIncluded in the mailbox priceAn add-on per IPA flat monthly price
Who it suitsMost senders starting out or sending modest volumeSteady senders who want their own reputationAgencies and high-volume teams

Providers do not publish a single volume threshold for keeping a dedicated IP established. Our recommendation: choose one only if you send every working day at a volume you can sustain.

What do providers charge for a dedicated IP or server?

Examples from providers' own pages, checked 15 November 2026, as each page states them:

ProviderIPs and price, as published
InfraforgeDedicated IP add-on $99 per IP per month
MailpoolShared/rotating IPs on the SMTP tier; dedicated IP $200/server/month
WinnrShared IPs; dedicated IPs $20 each per month on Enterprise
MailreefDedicated IP included; Agency Flex $249/month month-to-month; Agency $240/month with 12-month commitment; Enterprise custom quote. Plus $0.001 per send.

How can you check the IP you send from?

Open a message you sent at a mailbox you control and read its headers. The earliest Received line added by your provider's server shows the sending IP. With that address you can:

  • look it up on public blocklists, such as Spamhaus's lookup tool;
  • check that its reverse DNS (PTR) record returns a host name, and that the host name resolves back to the IP;
  • ask your provider whether the IP is shared, how many customers use it and how it handles a customer who sends spam.

On a shared pool the IP may change between messages, which is normal for rotated pools. A listing on a major blocklist is worth raising with your provider the same day, whichever model you use.

Does a dedicated IP improve inbox placement?

Not by itself. A dedicated IP removes other customers' behaviour from your results. It also removes the cover of their good behaviour: a new dedicated IP has no history, and a sender with poor lists will damage it faster than a large, well-run pool would show. Domain reputation, authentication, list quality and content still decide most outcomes. Neither option guarantees the inbox.

What does Outboxes use?

Outboxes runs on shared infrastructure on our servers in Germany, priced per inbox per month. We refuse orders that look like spam or phishing, because they would harm the IPs other customers share.

Sources

  1. Infraforge pricing (dedicated IP add-on)
  2. Mailpool pricing (dedicated IP)
  3. Winnr pricing (dedicated IPs)
  4. Mailreef pricing (dedicated server)
  5. Google: Email sender guidelines
  6. Spamhaus

Questions

Is a dedicated IP better for cold email?

It isolates you from other customers, which helps if you send steady volume with clean lists. For low or irregular volume, a well-managed shared pool is often the simpler choice. Neither guarantees the inbox.

How much does a dedicated IP cost?

It depends on the provider and the model. As their pages state them: Infraforge: Dedicated IP add-on $99 per IP per month; Mailpool: Shared/rotating IPs on the SMTP tier; dedicated IP $200/server/month; Winnr: Shared IPs; dedicated IPs $20 each per month on Enterprise.

What happens if another customer on a shared IP sends spam?

The shared IP's reputation can drop for everyone until the provider removes that customer and the reputation recovers.

Related guides and tools

From €0.67 per inbox · 25 inboxes minimum

See pricing