Short answer
Cold emails usually go to spam because of missing or failing SPF, DKIM or DMARC, new domains or mailboxes sent at volume without warm-up, sudden volume spikes, lists that bounce, recipients marking mail as spam, shared or suspicious links and tracking domains, or the content. Check them in that order.
Written by Outboxes, which sells private SMTP mailboxes for cold email: one of the options this guide describes.
In what order should you check the causes?
| Cause | Quick check | Usual fix |
|---|---|---|
| Authentication | Show original in Gmail | Correct SPF, DKIM and DMARC records |
| No warm-up | Domain and mailbox age | Pause campaigns, warm up about two weeks |
| Volume spike | Daily sends per mailbox | Lower rate, more mailboxes |
| Bounces | Bounce rate per campaign | Verify the list, remove hard bounces |
| Complaints | Postmaster Tools spam rate | Better targeting, easy opt-out |
| Links and tracking | Tracking domain and link targets | Custom tracking domain, fewer links |
| Content | Read it as the recipient | Plainer, shorter, relevant |
Start with what you can check in minutes and what breaks everything when it is wrong. The order below is our recommendation, from causes that are quick to check and common to those that are slower to diagnose. Spam filters weigh many signals together; one cause rarely explains everything, and no checklist guarantees the inbox. Each receiving service decides placement with its own signals, including how its users react to your mail.
Before you change anything, find out where the problem is. Compare domains and mailboxes in your sequencer: if one domain bounces or stops getting replies while the others are fine, the cause is on that domain. If every domain drops at once, look at what they share: the list, the message, the tracking domain or the provider.
1. Is authentication passing?
Check: send a message to a Gmail address you control, open it, choose Show original and read the SPF, DKIM and DMARC results. Look up the domain's TXT records for one SPF record, a DKIM key at the right selector and a DMARC record.
Change: fix any FAIL first. Merge duplicate SPF records, publish the DKIM key your provider gives you, and add DMARC. See SPF, DKIM and DMARC.
2. Was a new domain or mailbox warmed up?
Check: the domain's registration date and how long each mailbox ran warm-up before its first campaign.
Change: if it was under about two weeks, pause campaigns on that mailbox and let warm-up run. See cold email warm-up.
3. Did volume jump?
Check: each mailbox's daily sends over the last few weeks in your sequencer. A jump from 10 a day to 50 looks different to receivers from a steady rise.
Change: bring each mailbox back to a lower daily rate and add mailboxes for volume. See how many mailboxes and domains.
4. Is the list bouncing?
Check: the bounce rate per campaign. Hard bounces mean addresses that do not exist; a high rate tells receivers the list was not collected with care.
Change: verify addresses before sending, remove hard bounces at once, and be careful with catch-all domains, which accept every address during sending and may bounce later.
5. Are recipients marking the mail as spam?
Check: the spam rate in Google Postmaster Tools for your domain, if your volume to Gmail is large enough to show data, and your reply tone: complaints often arrive with "remove me" replies.
Change: tighten targeting, make opting out easy and honour it at once. Google and Yahoo require a spam rate below 0.3%, and Google asks senders to stay below 0.1%. See bulk sender rules.
6. Are links or the tracking domain hurting you?
Check: whether open and click tracking uses your sequencer's shared tracking domain or your own, and which domains your links point to. Link shorteners and domains with a poor reputation carry that reputation into your email.
Change: set up a custom tracking domain on each sending domain, use few links in a first email, and consider turning off open tracking, which adds a tracking image to every message.
7. Is it the content?
Check: the message as a recipient would see it: length, images, attachments, formatting, and whether it reads as written for that person.
Change: plain text or light formatting, no attachments in a first email, a clear sender and a reason to write to this person. Content matters, but it rarely rescues a set-up failing on points 1 to 5.