Short answer
Keep the old mailboxes sending while you order new ones, set up DNS on each domain, connect the new accounts to your sequencer and warm them up for about two weeks. Then move campaign volume across gradually and cancel the old provider last. Existing mail can be copied over IMAP; sending reputation and warm-up history do not move with you.
Written by Outboxes, which sells private SMTP mailboxes for cold email: one of the options this guide describes.
Why keep the old set-up running?
New mailboxes need warm-up before they carry campaign volume. If you cancel the old provider first, you stop sending for at least two weeks. Run both side by side, and accept paying for both for about a month.
Should you move existing domains or start with new ones?
- New domains are the cleaner switch. The old domains keep working with the old provider until you cancel, and nothing changes under live campaigns.
- Existing domains can move, but the MX, SPF and DKIM records must change to the new provider. From that moment, mail to the old mailboxes stops arriving, and any mailbox still sending through the old provider fails SPF and DKIM. Move a domain only when its old mailboxes have finished their sequences.
Our recommendation: start with new domains where you can, and move an existing domain only if its reputation is good and it matters to you.
What are the steps?
| Step | What to do | Done when |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Inventory | List every domain, mailbox, sequence, registrar and renewal date with the old provider | You know what you pay for and when it renews |
| 2. Order | Order the new mailboxes; choose new domains or decide which existing ones will move | New accounts are delivered |
| 3. DNS | Per domain: MX, SPF, DKIM and DMARC for the new provider, plus the tracking domain | A test message shows SPF, DKIM and DMARC passing |
| 4. Connect | Import the new accounts into your sequencer by OAuth or SMTP/IMAP | Every account sends and receives a test |
| 5. Warm up | Start warm-up on every new mailbox | About two weeks without warm-up mail in spam |
| 6. Shift volume | Add new mailboxes to campaigns at a low daily rate; lower the old ones as the new rise | New mailboxes carry the full volume |
| 7. Finish | Let old sequences complete; read the last replies; copy or export the mail you want to keep | No live sequence uses an old mailbox |
| 8. Cancel | Cancel the old plan before its renewal date; transfer or keep domains you own | Written confirmation of the cancellation |
How fast should volume move to the new mailboxes?
Our recommendation: once warm-up has run about two weeks, give the new mailboxes a low daily rate in live campaigns and raise it each week while bounces and replies look normal. Lower the old mailboxes by the same amount so total volume stays steady. Keep the old ones sending until the new ones carry the full volume, then let the old sequences finish. A switch that keeps total volume flat is invisible to your pipeline; one that drops to zero for two weeks is not.
What does not move to the new provider?
- Mail you do not copy. Sent mail and replies stay with the old provider unless you copy them over IMAP or export them before you cancel. Many teams keep replies in the sequencer and need little of the old mailboxes' contents.
- IP reputation. It belongs to the old provider's IPs.
- Mailbox reputation and warm-up. New mailboxes start from zero, even on an existing domain.
- Domain reputation does stay with the domain, good or bad. A domain with a damaged reputation does not recover by changing provider.
What should you check before you cancel?
- Domains registered through the old provider are in your name and can be transferred, or you have decided to let them lapse.
- No campaign, warm-up or reply rule in the sequencer still points at an old mailbox.
- DNS on any domain you keep no longer lists the old provider in SPF, which also frees SPF lookups.
- You know whether the old provider refunds any unused period. Many do not.
What does this guide not cover?
It does not cover moving a company's main business email, which carries staff mailboxes, calendars and archives and needs a full migration plan. Cold email sending domains are simpler because the mailboxes hold little you need to keep.
Outboxes supplies new accounts and a prepared import file. From the order you can run a connection check on one mailbox, then copy its existing mail from the old mailbox over IMAP, from the source hosts Outboxes supports; ask us to check yours. A final copy can run after the MX switch while the old service is still available. Outboxes shows the DNS records to change and checks the result; it does not change DNS at another provider. Sending reputation and warm-up history do not move.